How to
choose document
management
software
for an
accounting firm
Choose document software by sending one real request and following the file to the end. A storage screen tells you little; the trip from request to approved return tells you everything. The tools are lined up in the document software comparison.
What should document management software do for an accounting firm?
It should handle five steps, from request to return, without files changing hands between tools.
| Step | What to check | In Firmary |
|---|---|---|
| Request | Reusable checklists with instructions and due dates | Requests, request templates and, when attached, an engagement organizer |
| Collect | Phone uploads with no account to create | PocketFirm: a link, a one-time code, the camera |
| Sort | Unrequested files, and tax form values | Review queue; tax forms read for a person to confirm |
| Keep | Versions and virus scanning | Earlier versions kept, every upload scanned |
| Return | Delivery and client approval | Delivery and approval of drafts in PocketFirm |
How do you test document collection before you buy?
Pick a friend outside the firm, send them a real request, and ask them to answer it on their phone with a paper document. Count the steps between the email and the finished upload, and watch where they hesitate.
In PocketFirm the client opens the link, enters the one-time code, taps the item and takes a photo. Then check the firm’s side: the file should be on the client, with nobody moving it by hand.
What should AI do in document management for accountants?
AI should read and sort, and leave the decision to a person. Useful AI works out what a file is, which year it belongs to and what the boxes on a tax form say, then hands that to a person to confirm.
In Firmary’s review queue, Firmary reads the forms it supports (wage statements, mortgage-interest 1098s, interest, dividend and broker 1099s, consolidated 1099 statements and partnership Schedule K-1s from Form 1065) and proposes each one’s type, tax year and box figures for a person to verify. Ask other vendors whether their AI features are part of the plan or extra: TaxDome’s AI add-on, for example, is $200 a month.1
Which security checks matter for accountants’ documents?
Check four things: that each firm’s data is separate, that owners sign in with more than a password, that uploads are scanned, and that there is a record of who did what. A client’s W-2 carries their Social Security number, so none of these is optional.
In Firmary, each firm’s data is kept apart, owners and admins sign in with multi-factor authentication, uploads pass a virus scan, and an audit log keeps each person’s actions on record.
How do you move a document archive into new software?
Move the archive with the clients it belongs to, and check it before anyone works from it. An archive moved separately from client records ends up in folders nobody can match to a client.
Firmary’s move reads documents along with clients, jobs and invoices from TaxDome, other practice software or spreadsheets; which files come over varies by source system and by what Firmary can parse from it. The firm checks the results before importing, clients receive nothing, client messages stay in the old tool, and the old tool is left alone. Questions about cost and switching cover timing.
Questions to ask in a demo
- Send a document request to my phone. Can I answer it with a photo of a paper W-2?
- Where does a file go when a client sends it without a request?
- Which tax forms does the software read, and what does it fill in?
- Who confirms the values the AI proposes?
- How do we reuse our standard checklist for every individual return?
- Can the client see what is still missing for this year’s return?
- Show me a draft return going to the client for approval.
- Is every upload scanned, and are earlier versions kept?
- Can we connect our existing Google Drive, OneDrive or Dropbox?
- Does a photo a client texts us end up in their documents?
- How does our current archive come across, and can we check it first?
A checklist to print
- Reusable request templates with due dates
- Clients upload or photograph from a phone, no app
- An attached organizer shows what’s still missing
- Unrequested files go to a review queue
- Tax forms read, values confirmed by a person
- Every upload virus-scanned
- Earlier versions kept
- Drafts approved by the client before delivery
- Our cloud storage can be connected
- Archive checked before switching
Request access to Firmary
Leave your work email and we’ll email you the next step.
Sources
Each product fact on this page links to a numbered source. Quotes are copied as the page’s text reads on the date shown, spacing included.
- 1
TaxDome
AI is $200 a month